唐某1、唐某2因火灾坠楼死亡生命权纠纷（上海502室火灾）

title: 146_唐某1、唐某2因火灾坠楼死亡生命权纠纷（上海502室火灾）

updated: 2026-08-04

唐某1、唐某2因火灾坠楼死亡生命权纠纷（上海502室火灾）

• 法院：上海市某人民法院
• 裁判日期：2024
• 案件类型：民事
• 案由/罪名：生命权纠纷
• 文书号：-
• 当事人：原告方某3等；被告方某1、方某2、邱某1、邱某2、邵某等
• 裁判结果摘要：502室拖线板手机充电器起火，被告未关大门致火情扩大，两原告亲属坠楼死亡，三被告应承担赔偿责任
• 来源：https://www.hshfy.sh.cn/shfy/web/flws_view.jsp?pa=adGFoPaOoMjAyNKOpu6YwMTE2w/Gz9TQ4MDS6xSZ3c3hoPTUPdcssz

正文

ԭ棺ij1 ԭ棺ij1 ԭ湲ͬίϴˣʱij 棺ij1 棺ij 棺ij2 湲ͬίϴˣij ԭij1ij1뱻ij1ijij2ȨȨȨһԺ202437ü׳2024415չͥ202438գҪתΪͨɺͥ202474ٴιͥԭij1ԭ湲ͬίϴʱij湲ͬίϴ˺ijͥμͥսᡣ ԭԺ湲֧ͬԭij2ɵĸʧ1,975,463.79ԪڶͥУԭΪ湲֧ͬԭij2ɵĸʧ1,975,581.79Ԫʵɣ2024110賿Ϻнɽijij´ij¥502ң¼502ң֣502ҡϺнɽijij´ij¥602ң¼602ң̶ͬջ٣602ij1ij2¥ij2飬2024116ijij֧ӳˡijij֧ӻ϶顷϶λַʱΪ20241103ʱ20λΪ502ҶϲڣΪ÷䶫ϲലͷԭΪ֡Ϊ502ҷ˼סˡլʱ602ҹ5˾סij2丸ĸԭ棬Լij2ijַ淽ij1ʱŽӵһ绰ʱΪ20241103ʱ3020룬ַʱ10ӣ˻602ҡԼ502ҺҲδرԼҴţ˻Ľһͬʱ淽ij2δڵһʱھ602סŨǺʱɥʧԾʱ䡣Ѹ٣ŨѶסΨһĹ¥ݣһȼڣij1ֻЯij2ϲ̨ܵȴԮſ̨ӣѬ˳¥ij2вסķӷֵԭ淽ʧڻַ淽ij1ʱȡԮʩ»ҲδԮӶ˱ķ淽ڱ¼дԵĹӦijе⳥Ρʸݡл䡷һǧһʮһǧһʮлϷȹ涨ԺϣС ƣȫͬԭȣij1ijDZʸ棬Ӧе⳥Ρ502ҷij2ס߰弰ֻij2ij2ӦеӦΡij1ijȻǷݲȨˣDzδסڸ÷ݣij1ijûij2ͬʵʩȨΪԻַӦеΡڶԭ淽ij3ڱղԭ˾ס˶ͨ¥ݽij1ij2Ҳȫʱͨ¥ģij1ȴij2ķ̨ͨûڵһʱӶ˱緢Ҹݻ¹ʵ602ҵijڲѬûԻյĺۼˣʱij1ij2ȥ߳ܣܻӺˣԭڱղӦӦij2Ρ Χύ֤ݣԺ֯˽֤ݽ֤Ե֤ݣԺȷϲھ֤Щ֤ΪԭύĻ¹϶顢ҽѧ֤顢ֱϵϵ֤ҽƼ¼ҽƷƱݡʦѷƱ¹ʵϡǼϢƬijƵƬȷƱݣύݡijǮijѯʱ¼֤ݣԺ֤£ԭύij1֤ʵԡϷԡȷϣԭύĻֺƵʵԡϷԡȷϡ УԺְȨijij֧ӵȡ502ҵ·ͼ502ƽͼ602ƽͼ502䲼ͼַλͼ¹϶ֺۼƷȡ嵥ϢǼDZֱӲƲʧŵǼDZ걨ֳ¼ֱӲƲʧ걨ŵǼDZ걨ֱӾʧͳƱ¹ʵʾƬֱӲƲʧͳƱӾϢǮijѯʱ¼桢ֳƬ˵ij2ѯʱ¼Σʬ챨桢ij1Ի¼ΣԱϢԭ漰ԱԺȡĸ֤ݵʵԡϷԡԾ飬Ժȷϲھ֤ ݵ˳;ȷϵ֤ݣԺ϶ʵ£ ijij֧2024116ճ֣2024xxxŻ¹϶飬¹ʻ20241103ʱ3020룬ԮܶӽӾϺнɽijij´ij¥502ҷ֣402ˮʧ502ҡ602Ҳ̶ͬջ٣602ҸŮij1У֤XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXij2Ů֤XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX¥£ij1ദۣij2ЧijŮ֤XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXֱˣ501ҡ601ҷ𣬹Լ130ƽס飬ԭ϶£϶ַʱΪ20241103ʱ20϶λΪϺнɽijij´ij¥502Ҷϲڣ϶Ϊ÷䶫ϲലͷ϶ԭΪ֡ ijij֧ӵġ¹϶ųֵĿܣΪϲലͷϷõ߰Ϊأ2ֻ߰ڻ·ʱҲδ·ۺۣݵʹij2ͷϵ߰ʹ6ֻ꣬Ϲģԭģij2˵ԭӦ5ߣ20ߣʹʧǿܴڵģ߰ϵijӲΣӴʧҲų߰ڲԭҲ֣Ȼ߰кûм·ۺۺ͵ۺۣӴ·ۺۣij2ֻʱģǷ·磬Ʋһأֳڣ·ǰǽδܵƻܹ϶ԭΪ֡ ֳ¼602ҷڲֺ502һͬʹ˴ľʻǽ壬ʹñʵڷдƷⴰȫѣƷأϲһϲֻʣܣ²̼ҳ̼أڲƷԼ1й̼ۼϲരڻۼڶϲ²̼ſҳϲ̼ڲϱ㻯ڻۼϲ̼ۼϲ̼²ãҳ̼ۼڴƷã¹ϲ𣬶ѬſڲѬƷڻδջ١ 2024110ջַʱ602ҹ5˾סij2丸ĸij1ij1Լij1Ůij2ij1ĸij502ҷݵij2һ˾ס502ҷݲȨij2ĸĸij1ijȨǼΪ201312¡ַij1ij2ijͨ¥롣ij1Яij2602ұգ¥ ijij´ij601ҵijɳѯʱ¼гְ̨֮Ĵ⿴Ҷ602ҵһеĺһСŮеſŴ¼ܣֱŮеѾڿյ״̬ˣҶ˵Ѿ˵绰ˣһ˲ǸͬԼŮһ¥ϵȥˡ ijij´ij501ҵǮijɳѯʱ¼г˯ʱԺţҾŲ鿴Ƕ502ҵСšСӾʹ˯£ʲô飬˵ŻˣҸϿ챨Ҳ˯£ϱˡ꾯֮Ҿż˯ˣҷŻ̫ŨˣѬܲҾʹ·˳ȥ ij2ɳһѯʱ¼гԼסϺнɽijij´ij¥502Ҷϲ䣬Լ56֮ǰӺҾסֵʱһסҵĸĸסڵء2024110賿3ʱ20ңڷﱻζǺѣ֮ҷ˯Ĵϲ̨ʽDZѾˣдͷ߰Ҳ𣬵Ƿڵϣλãܹ߰һ߰ӷӳڴͷ棬ֻ߲磬ֱҲ磬Ե߰ԴҲǽڴͷ߰ϣԵ߰ڵ棬ʱδػĻŵĴ״̬Żȥˮڴͷȥ˽ˮЧܴѾȥˣҾøھ501ҵķţæھӴź119ȻҾ¥ˣұ˽˸ֻҸĵ绰1500038XXXXڶ绰ͨҰŻ˵˺ҸϹˡҾһֱ¥µˡԼ4֮ǰĵԣǴӾȫ´̨ʽԼ4,000ԪҡƽʱһֱŻģڲػģϰʱҲһֱŵģʱҰҹػοûйػˡҷڴͷ߰ʱȽϳˣԼ6֮ǰͿʼʹˡҵֻ1ǰƻ14ֻõֻǴİɵĿͷͳߣ20ߵģƻԭװijߺ5ߵġҵĵֱҲƻƷƵģԼ1֮ǰģõԭװijĵ硣յҲǿŵġĵ豸ûˡ ij2ɳڶѯʱ¼Уʣ˯ʱǿŻǹŵģij2ǹŵġҳȥźͽŶǴģû˳ֹϡʣ˷ԺЩ飿ij2501ұȻµ¥뱱രʿֻص¥ſڿ¥ˣֻصﱱɳһ·ʱ·Ѿвڻˣֱ̳ˮݣʱѾ1.3ңʱûı͵¥ˡʣԺûľٴ룿ij2ʱ501ŵʱڴŻˡ ִ¼Ǽ¼ij1ĶԻУij1Сģȥģץס˵ġҪȥIJҪȥġʵǡѬץסˣʵץסˡҹԺѾʲôˣ̡ˣȻŮܵǣǶſߵģҲ֪ʲôˣ̨DZߣҾѾûʶˣûʶһʶûˡDZߣ̷Ŀһ㣬ͿˣܣҾȥDZңǸʱѾʲôˡſڣСҲȥọ̈̄һ·ҲûСû̫ʶˡǸʱһʿӡ Ժ2024110գij1֧ԭ淽50,000Ԫ2024114գij1֧ԭ淽50,000Ԫڻij1ijijҽԺijijԺƵ˻С ԺΪ齹Ϊһԭ淽ij4ķйij1ijǷӦеȨΡ һԭ淽ij4ķй Ϊԭ淽ij5ͨ¥ij1Яij2δܼʱܵصѡԭ淽ij3ڹԴˣԭ淽ͥгŮ20꣬ϡ϶ǷdzõʱϡϾͳȥˡԭij1Ҳ긻ǿijˣлˤһӣij1Э´Ӷ¥ij1ҪΪչij2ij2ֻ꣬ΪһôССѣǶδɣָǽššʴӣij1ںѰij2˴ʧ¥ĻᣬֻѰҶܵ·ߡǶڵ䷿̨ϣҲûġ 飬ԺΪȣַʱ602Ҿסij1ij1ij2ij1ĸijԼij1ĴŮij2ijѾ70꣬ij2ͶСѧ꼶ַʱij2Ŷ븸ĸƿأ̵ķ䣬ij1Ѱij2ij1ijڼ˼ӵ£ij1ij1ֱжӡˣһͥĴʽˣij1ij1Ѿ˶ij2ļְ Σijı¼ij1˳ij1ǹ¥Яij2̨Ϊ˺ʿſڴ¼ϣ¼ܲ¥ڱյĴʩǷڲȻij1ܹͨ¥룬ij1Ѱij2Ӷһʱ䣬ݳڻַʱڶʱھͿӣij1ọ̈̄һ·ҲûСӡ֤ʵˣʹij1ܹ¥룬ij1ij2Ҳ˳ͨ¥롣ڶܵĵص㣬ȻŶͳܾͲصĺǣЩºԷڻַʱһʧ룬ij1ڸü䷿ҵij2ʱ̨DZߣҾѾûʶˣûʶһʶûˡɼʱij1״̬ѷȫѣʶij1Яij2ıշʽԺԿ ij2ڷּŻвδñǽˮδڵһʱ佫ʹּС뿪гҪ501ҵǮijæȴûйϼеĽԴӾ˻ӡҸ501ŵʱŻ𣬿ɼij2δھӼһһѻֵķԭһij1ȷŻˣij2ʧ˻֣ڷֺһ̶ʧûмʱԭһ ϣԭij1ij1ķӦеΣӦȨɵʧеȫΡ ڱij1ijǷӦеȨΡ ϹͬʵʩȨΪģӦеΡУ502ҷֵԭǵϣij2Ϊַʱľסߣ豸ʹߣΪȨԭ漰飬ij1ijǷӦеȨ,ij1ijδס502ңȨˣڸʵԭij1ͥгһסģֻûס˵ססģһλΣƵʡΪǼҵľ۲Ҳܶࡣǰһij2Ůѣĸסij1ijֻżס ԺΪȣ502ҷϵij1ij2013꣬ʱij2δ꣬ɼij1ij502ҷݼڵ豸нϴĿơȨҸij2ijַʱͷ߰崦𣬸֮߰ǰͿʼʹáˣ߰岻ųϵij1ijڶȻֵ죬ij2һ˾ס502ңij2ʱҰҹػԭij1502۲ͣɼij1ijǽȫij2һ˾סճʹø÷ݲйij2ij1ijϵĸŮϵһķ͵Ĺϵͬʹij1ijÿסڸ÷ݣ϶÷ϵڼͥס˹ͬʹá502ҷֵԭǵϣϵIJ뷿ݵճסʹϢϢءϣԺ϶ϵ502ҷݵĹˣԷڵʩ߰ȵΪʹˡˣɵĻ֣ΪͬȨˣӦɵеΡ ݡԺ⳥÷Ľ͡ع涨һͥսʱһͳϺ⳥Ժԭʧ϶£ 1ҽƷѣԭ淽642.79ԪҽƷѼ120ȷ118Ԫ飬Ժȷϣ 2⳥ԭ淽1,789,540Ԫ飬Ժȷϣ 3ɥѣԭ淽73,098Ԫ飬Ժȷϣ 4οԭ淽50,000ԪΪߣԺDZĹ̶ȡأԭ֧֣ 5ѣԭżɥµѣԭ淽ŽΪϺƽ406.1Ԫ?/죬3ÿ10죬12,183ԪɷԺˣΪԭŹߡԺΪԭѾɥѣӦɥУӦţʲ֧֣ 6ʦѣԭ50,000ԪΪߣԺϱʵ֧10,000Ԫ ϣӦ֧ԭij1ij1ʧ1,923,398.79ԪѾ֧ԭ100,000Ԫ50,000Ԫԭȷij1ƣԭ沢δڱжij1ʧ⳥Ҫʶڸñ50,000ԪԺڱеֿۣij1ʧ⳥ԵֿۡжԱ֧50,000ԪԵֿۺ滹֧ԭ1,873,398.79Ԫ ݴˣաл䡷һǧһʮһǧһʮһǧһʮһǧһٰʮлϷһʮ֮涨о£ һij1ijij2ڱоЧ֮ʮ⳥ԭij1ij1ʧ1,873,398.79Ԫ ԭij1ij1 δоָڼиǮӦաлϷڶʮ֮涨ӱ֧ڼծϢ 22,579.17ԪƲȫ5,000Ԫ27,579.17Ԫԭij1ij11,427.17Ԫij1ijij226,152Ԫ 粻ооʹ֮ʮڣԺݽ״Է˵ϺеһмԺ ط һл䡷 һǧһʮΪֺȨģӦеȨΡ շɹ涨ƶΪй䲻֤ԼûйģӦеȨΡ һǧһʮϹͬʵʩȨΪģӦеΡ һǧһʮֺģӦ⳥ҽƷѡѡͨѡӪѡסԺʳѵΪƺͿ֧ĺãԼٵ롣ɲмģӦ⳥߷ѺͲм⳥ģӦ⳥ɥѺ⳥ һǧһٰʮֺȻȨؾģȨȨ⳥ شʧֺȻ˾ضؾģȨȨ⳥ лϷ һʮͥսᣬӦооǰܹģԽе⣬ⲻɵģӦʱо ڶʮִδоöָڼиǮģӦӱ֧ڼծϢִδоöָڼģӦ֧н ذţ 飺